Globalisation, indigenous tourism, and the politics of place in Amaicha (NW Argentine Andes)

Gerhard Rainer

Abstract


Argentina is a country that has represented itself over centuries as white and European. Over the last decades, however, indigenous movements have increased strongly in visibility and importance. This investigation considers this background in analysing the complex relationship between the growing importance of tourism and indigenous politics for self-determination and autonomy in the Andean village of Amaicha (NW-Argentina). The annual Pachamama celebration held by the indigenous Amaicha community presents the ideal setting for this research as it has simultaneously become a ‘national tourist festivity’ in the context of recent government efforts to promote a culturally diverse Argentina for tourism development. Through long-term ethnographic field work and by applying a methodological framework that combines the interpretation of visual material with careful empirical research this study presents a differentiated analysis of the political implications of indigenous tourism. The findings show that conflicts between the indigenous community and governmental institutions tend not to be about tourism and place promotion as such, but rather tourism has become a central arena where struggles over political control are manifested and mediated. Furthermore, cultural politics in Amaicha have recently been reassembled through both embodied practices and the use of cultural symbols during the Pachamama festivity. Finally, while relational conceptualisations of place as constituted through wider connections have gained momentum in academia, the results from this investigation show that an essentialised understanding of culture and identity as rooted in place is promoted for tourism, and emphasised by the indigenous community in order to legitimise claims for territorial and political rights. The goal of the paper is thus to contribute to a nuanced picture of emergent indigenous geographies in Argentina.

Keywords


Indigenous tourism, Pachamama celebration, globalisation, indigenous rights, NW Argentine Andes

Full Text:

PDF

References


Agius, P., T. Jenkin, S. Jarvis, R. Howitt and R. Williams 2007: (Re)asserting indigenous rights and jurisdictions within a politics of place: Transformative nature of native ­title negotiations in South Australia. – Geographical Research 45 (2): 194-202

Andolina, R., N. Laurie and S.A. Radcliffe 2009: Indigenous development in the Andes: Culture, power and trans­nationalism. – Durham, NC et al.

Babb, F.E. 2012: Theorizing gender, race, and cultural tourism in Latin America: a view from Peru and Mexico. – Latin American Perspectives 39 (6): 36-50

Bebbington, A. 2004: Movements and modernizations, markets and municipalities: indigenous federations in rural Ecuador. – In: Peet, R. and M. Watts (eds.): Liberation ecologies: environment, development, social movements. – 2nd edition. – London et al.: 394-421

Bertoncello, R. 2006: Turismo, territorio y sociedad. El “mapa turístico de la Argentina”. – In: Geraiges de Lemos, A.I., M. Arroyo and M.L. Silveira (eds.): América Latina: cidade, campo e turismo. – São Paulo et al.: 317-335

Bertoncello, R. 2008: Presentación. – In: Bertoncello, R. and C.A. Troncoso (eds.): Turismo y geografía. Lugares y patrimonio natural-cultural de la Argentina. – Buenos Aires: 5-17

Boullosa-Joly, M. 2010: Tourisme, patrimonialisation et ­politique. Un cas d’école: la « fête nationale de la Pachamama » (Nord-Ouest argentin). – Cahiers des Amériques latines 65 (3): 103-120

Briones, C. 2005: Formaciones de alteridad: contextos globales, procesos nacionales y provinciales. – In: Briones, C. (ed.): Cartografías argentinas. Políticas indigenistas y formaciones provinciales de alteridad. – Buenos Aires: 11-44

Butler, R. and T. Hinch (eds.) 2007: Tourism and indigenous peoples. Issues and implications. – Amsterdam et al.

Castree, N. 2004a: Differential geographies: place, indigenous rights and ‘local’ resources. – Political Geography 23 (2): 133-167

Castree, N. 2004b: Economy and culture are dead! Long live economy and culture! – Progress in Human Geography 28 (2): 204-226

Chamosa, O. 2008: Indigenous or Criollo: The myth of white Argentina in Tucumán’s Calchaquí Valley. – Hispanic American Historical Review 88 (1): 71-106

Chamosa, O. 2010: The Argentine folklore movement. Sugar elites, criollo workers, and the politics of cultural nationalism, 1900-1955. – Tucson

Clarín 11/02/2013: Tributo entre cerros y valles. – Online available at: http://www.clarin.com/viajes/Tributo-cerros-valles_0_426557373.html, 14/07/2014

Coombes, B., J.T. Johnson and R. Howitt 2013: Indigenous geographies II: The aspirational spaces in postcolonial politics – reconciliation, belonging and social provision. – Progress in Human Geography 37 (5): 691-700

Crang, M. 2004: Cultural geographies of tourism. – In: Lew, A.A., C.M. Hall and A.M. Williams (eds.): A companion to tourism. – Oxford et al.: 74-84

Crang, M. 2010: Visual methods and methodologies. – In: DeLyser, D., S. Herbert, S. Aitken, M. Crang and L. McDowell (eds.): The SAGE handbook of qualitative geography. – Los Angeles: 208-224

Cresswell, T. 2004: Place. A short introduction. – Malden, Mass.

Cruz, R. 1997: La ‘construcción’ de identidades étnicas en el Tucumán colonial: los amaichas y los tafíes en el debate sobre su ‘verdadera’ estructura étnica. – In: Lorandi, A.M., R. Boixadós, C.V. Bunster and B. Cremonte (eds.): El Tucumán colonial y Charcas I. – Buenos Aires: 253-282

Ente Tucumán Turismo, Gobierno de Tucumán 2009: Guía Invertir en Turismo Tucumán 2009/2010. – San Miguel de Tucumán. – Online available at: http://www.educativa.com/servicios/Descargas/Tucuman/es/pdf/Invertir_en_Turismo_Tucuman.pdf, 19/02/2015

Escobar, A. 2001: Culture sits in places: reflections on globalism and subaltern strategies of localization. – Political Geography 20 (2): 139-174

Frantz, K. and R. Howitt 2012: Geography for and with indigenous peoples: indigenous geographies as challenge and invitation. – GeoJournal 77 (6): 727-731

Garrett, B.L. 2011: Videographic geographies: Using digital video for geographic research. – Progress in Human Geography 35 (4): 521-541

Gordillo, G. and S. Hirsch 2003: Indigenous struggles and contested identities in Argentina. Histories of invisibilization and reemergence. – Journal of Latin American Anthropology 8 (3): 4-30

Hall, M. 2007: Politics, power and indigenous tourism. – In: Butler, R. and T. Hinch (eds.). Tourism and indigenous peoples. Issues and implications. – Amsterdam et al.: 305-318

Hall, S. 1996: Introduction: Who needs ‘identity’? – In: Hall, S. and P. Du Gay (eds.): Questions of cultural identity. – London: 1-17

Hall, S. 1997: The spectacle of the ‘other’. – In: Hall, S. (ed.): Representation. Cultural representations and signifying practices. – London: 223-290

Hiernaux-Nicolas, D. 2002: Turismo e imaginarios. – In: ­Hiernaux­-Nicolas, D., A. Cordero and L. van Duynen Montijn (eds.): Imaginarios sociales y turismo sostenible. – Cuadernos de ciencias sociales 123. – San José (Costa Rica): 7-36

Hinch, T. 2004: Indigenous people and tourism. – In: Lew, A.A., C.M. Hall and A.M. Williams (eds.): A companion to tourism. – Oxford et al.: 246-258

Hinch, T. and R. Butler 2007: Introduction: revisiting common ground. – In: Butler, R. and T. Hinch (eds.): Tourism and indigenous peoples. Issues and implications. – Amsterdam et al.: 1-12

Information Booklet of the Indigenous Community of Amaicha. Juridical Personality 3276

Isla, A.R. 2009: Los usos políticos de la identidad. Criollos, indígenas y estado. – Buenos Aires

Katz, C. 2001): On the grounds of globalization: A topography for feminist political engagement. – Signs: Journal of Women in Culture and Society 26 (4): 1213-1234

Kindon, S. 2003: Participatory video in geographic research: A feminist practice of looking? – Area 35 (2): 142-153

Li, T.M. 2001: Relational histories and the production of difference on Sulawesi’s upland frontier. – Journal of Asian Studies 60 (1): 41-66

Lorimer, J. 2010: Moving image methodologies for more-than-human geographies. – Cultural Geographies 17 (2): 237-258

Manasse, B. and P. Arenas 2009: Antropología y arqueología en contextos de nuevas luchas por la tierra. – In: Manasse, B. and P. Arenas (eds.): Arqueología, tierras y territorios: conflictos e intereses. – San Miguel de Tucumán: 13-52

Massey, D.B. 1999: Power-geometries and the politics of space-time. Hettner-Lecture 1998. – Hettner-Lectures 2. – Heidelberg

Massey, D.B. 2005: For space. – London et al.

Meethan, K., A. Anderson and S. Miles 2006: Preface. – In: Meethan, K., A. Anderson and S. Miles (eds.): Tourism consumption and representation: narratives of place and self. – Wallingford et al.: xiii-xv

Ministerio de Agricultura, Ganadería y Pesca 2012: Boletín Informativo de la Subsecretaría de Agricultura Familiar. – Online available at: http://www.boletin-ssaf.com.ar/?p=1139, 13/09/2013

Ministerio de Turismo de la Nación 2011: Plan federal estratégico de turismo sustentable: Turismo 2020. Actualización 2011. –Buenos Aires. – Online available at: http://siet.desarrolloturistico.gov.ar/recursos/documentos/SubDoc/fd217bc5b686d951cdc21ec84792279335f7f055.pdf, 19/02/2015

Mitchell, D. 2000: Cultural geography. A critical introduction. – Oxford et al.

Moore, D.S. 1998: Subaltern struggles and the politics of place: Remapping resistance in Zimbabwe’s eastern highlands. – Cultural Anthropology 13 (3): 344-381

Moore, D.S. 2005: Suffering for territory. Race, place, and power in Zimbabwe. – Durham et al.

Neumann, R.P. 2005: Making political ecology. – London

Notzke, C. 2006: The stranger, the native and the land. Perspectives on indigenous tourism. – Concord

Paolasso, P., G. Rainer, F. Ruiz Peyré und M. Coy 2013: Entwicklungstendenzen im ländlichen Raum Nordwest-­Argentiniens. – Geographische Rundschau 65 (12): 14-21

Perreault, T. 2001: Developing identities: indigenous mobilization, rural livelihoods, and resource access in Ecuadorian Amazonia. – Cultural Geographies 8 (4): 381-413

Perreault, T. 2003: Changing places: transnational networks, ethnic politics, and community development in the Ecuadorian Amazon. – Political Geography 22 (1): 61-88

Perreault, T. and B. Green 2013: Reworking the spaces of indigeneity: the Bolivian ayllu and lowland autonomy movements compared. – Environment and Planning D: Society and Space 31 (1): 43-60

Pink, S. 2008: Mobilising visual ethnography: making routes, making place and making images. – Forum Qualitative­ Sozialforschung / Forum: Qualitative Social Research 9 (3): Art. 36. – Online available at: http://nbn-resolving.de/urn:nbn:de:0114-fqs0803362, 19/02/2015

Provincia de Tucumán 2006: Constitución de la Provincia de Tucumán. – San Miguel de Tucumán. – Online available at: http://rig.tucuman.gov.ar/leyes/scan/scan/L-0-0606 2006.pdf, 19/02/2015

Radcliffe, S.A. 1997: The geographies of indigenous self-representation in Ecuador: Hybridity, gender and resistance. – European Review of Latin American and Caribbean Studies / Revista Europea de Estudios Latinoamericanos y del Caribe 63: 9-27

Rainer, G. and M. Malizia 2014: Los countries en el country. Migración de amenidad, vino de altura y urbanizaciones cerradas en Cafayate (Salta, Argentina). – Journal of Latin American Geography 13 (1): 39-66

Rainer, G. and S.B. Morales Gaitán 2014: Globalization and the impacts of leisure-induced mobilities: lessons from Tafí del Valle (NW Argentine Andes). – Tourism Review International 18 (3): 179-192

Rodríguez, L.B. 2008: Mestizos o indios puros? El Valle Calchaquí y los primeros antropólogos. – Avá. Revista de Antropología 13: 77-96

Rodríguez, L.B. 2009: Los usos del sistema judicial, la retórica y la violencia en torno a un reclamo sobre ­tierras comunales. Amaicha del Valle, siglo XIX. – Runa 30 (2): 135-150

Rose, G. 2007: Visual methodologies. An introduction to the interpretation of visual materials. – 2nd edition. – ­London et al.

Rossiter, D. and P.K. Wood 2005: Fantastic topographies: neo-liberal responses to Aboriginal land claims in British ­Columbia. – The Canadian Geographer 49 (4): 352-366

Salazar, N.B. 2009: Imaged or imagined? cultural representations and the ‘tourismification’ of peoples and places. – Cahiers d’Études africaines 49 (1-2): 49-71

Salazar, N.B. 2012: Tourism imaginaries: a conceptual approach. – Annals of Tourism Research 39 (2): 863-882

Schurr, C. 2012: Visual ethnography for performative geographies: how women politicians perform identities on Ecuadorian stages. – Geographica Helvetica 67 (4): 195-202

Schurr, C. 2013: Towards an emotional electoral geography: The performativity of emotions in electoral campaigning in Ecuador. – Geoforum 49: 114-126

Secretaría de Turismo de la Nación Argentina 2005: Plan Federal Estratégico de Turismo. – Buenos Aires

Secretaría de Turismo de la Argentina 2008: Argentina invita a descubrir un país de oportunidades. – Guía de oportunidades para el sector turismo. – Buenos Aires

Sosa, J. 2011: Politicas de desarrollo turístico y comunidades originarias: el caso de Amaicha del Valle en la Provincia de Tucumán. – Publicar En Antropología y Ciencias Sociales 9 (10): 129-152

Stronza, A. 2008: Through a new mirror: Reflections on tourism and identity in the Amazon. – Human Organization 67 (3): 244-257

Sylvain, R. 2002: “Land, water, and truth”: San identity and global indigenism. – American Anthropologist 104 (4): 1074-1085

Sylvain, R. 2005: Disorderly development: Globalization and the idea of “culture” in the Kalahari. – American Ethnologist 32 (3): 354-370

Troncoso, C.A. 2012: Turismo y patrimonio en la Quebrada de Humahuaca. Lugar, actores y conflictos en la defini­ción de un destino turístico argentino. – PASOS. ­Revista de Turismo y Patrimonio Cultural. Colección PASOS ­Edita 9. – Santa Cruz de Tenerife

Urry, J. 1990: The tourist gaze. Leisure and travel in contemporary societies. – London

Valdivia, G. 2005: On indigeneity, change, and representa­tion in the northeastern Ecuadorian Amazon. – Environment and Planning A 37 (2): 285-303

Warren, S.D. 2009: How will we recognize each other as Mapuche? Gender and ethnic identity performances in Argentina. – Gender & Society 23 (6): 768-789

Watson, A. and K. Till 2010: Ethnography and participant observation. – In: DeLyser, D., S. Herbert, S. Aitken, M. Crang and L. McDowell (eds.): The SAGE handbook of qualitative geography. – Los Angeles: 121-137

Watts, M.J. 1991: Mapping meaning, denoting difference, imagining identity: Dialectical images and postmodern geographies. – Geografiska Annaler B 73 (1): 7-16


Refbacks

  • There are currently no refbacks.



If a manuscript is accepted for publication, the authors will be asked to pay an Article Publication Fee to cover publications costs.

Die ERDE charges the authors a page fee of € 25.– (no VAT required) for accepted and published articles to cover a part of the production costs. An average paper with 14 printed pages thus costs € 350.– (article processing charge).

This fee includes full open access to contents, no additional fee is necessary to allow everybody to access the PDF of the published paper. This means: you can freely distribute the final PDF, present it on your homepage and make links to the PDF from other web sites. In detail, Die ERDE uses the following copyright license:

Creative Commons License Articles published in Die ERDE are licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution-ShareAlike 4.0 International License.

In April 2018 the Editorial Manager has changed. Please address all inquiries and correspondence to Dr. Verena Sandner Le Gall, sandner[AT]geographie.uni-kiel.de.



Archive

Since 2011 all issues are openly accessible via this link
Older issues (back as far as 1833) are also open-access available – via www.digizeitschriften.de